Logo Hawk
Get a FREE
Financing Available

Tile Roofing Versus Shingle Roofing: Which is Better for Florida Homes?

Sep 30, 2021

A close-up image of a barrel tile roof.

Replacing the roof on your home in Florida is a major investment, and you want to be sure you’re getting the best value. However, with so many materials and brands available, it can be difficult to determine what’s best for your home. Here, we’ll discuss two of the most popular styles of roofing for Florida homes—tile and asphalt shingles—to help guide you in making your decision.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Tile & Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Before comparing and contrasting tile and shingle roofing, it’s important to note that the quality of both of these materials, as well as the workmanship of the companies that install them, varies widely. Both tile and shingle roofing can make an excellent, long-term investment if you choose the right product and have it installed by experts. Some typical differences between tile and asphalt shingles include:


Tile is generally the more expensive option, so if you’re looking for the most cost-effective roof replacement product, shingles will likely come out on top. However, you should also consider longevity. Tile roofing tends to last significantly longer, so if you’re planning on remaining in your home long-term, tile might be the right investment.


In Florida, asphalt shingles tend to wear out quicker due to intense sun and wind. However, shingle products are available that are designed for local homes and can easily last for decades. Ultimately, in terms of weather resistance and longevity, tile is typically the winner.

Energy Efficiency

High-quality shingles that are well suited to Florida homes can do a great job of reflecting UV rays and making it easier to keep homes cool. On the other hand, tile is an excellent insulator and can also help to significantly boost home thermal performance. When it comes to energy efficiency, whether you choose tile or asphalt shingles, the most important factor will be choosing a high-quality product.

Visual Appeal

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and roofing is no exception. Many Florida homeowners prefer the traditional appeal and dimensional appearance of tile roofing. However, premium asphalt shingles can also go a long way toward improving a home’s curb appeal. For example, options are available with bold colors and accentuated shadow lines to mimic the look of natural materials, such as wood shake.

Grayhawk Remodeling Offers the Best Value for Tile & Shingle Roofing Replacements

At Grayhawk Remodeling, we specialize in roof replacement and repair for homeowners in Sarasota County. No matter what type of roofing you choose, you can be sure it will be of the highest quality, installed to the highest standards by factory-trained experts, and backed by industry-leading warranties.

If you’d like to learn more about our tile and shingle roofing and which is best for your home, contact Grayhawk Remodeling today.

Get It Right
Google 4.8 Facebook 4.5 Guild Quality 4.5

“This is an outstanding company with excellent service. I would not hesitate to use again.”

“Very professional and attention to detail great to work with. Definitely would use them again!”

“Project Manager really cares about the homeowners! Grayhawk Roofing looks out for your property as if it were their own.”

“Grayhawk is an experienced area general contractor, does a quality job at reasonable prices and stands behind his work.”

“We've used Grayhawk for three major projects and have been happy each time - obviously, or we wouldn't keep going back.”

“Excellent service and QUALITY windows! I would highly receommend Grayhawk Systems.”

5 Stars Out of 6 Reviews
Your Experts
Right Next Door